I met Clara in a queue outside the old Screen Cinema when we were both nineteen and pretending we knew more about foreign films than we did. It was raining with that soft Dublin rain that gets into your sleeves, and she offered me half of her umbrella as if we had arranged to meet there. By the end of the film, which neither of us understood, we were laughing outside Trinity College, making serious promises to become interesting people.
For three years, we were almost inseparable. We drank bad coffee near Grafton Street, walked along the canal in Portobello, and spent Sundays in second-hand bookshops, buying novels we rarely finished. I loved her in the quiet, certain way a young man loves when he has not yet learned that certainty is not the same as timing.
Clara’s family moved to Galway when her father got sick, and everything between us became train times, missed calls, and letters. Actual letters, because she said texts made feelings look lazy. She wrote in blue ink, always on paper with tiny flowers in the corner. At first, the letters came every week. Then every month. Then one arrived in April, telling me she was engaged to a man named Stephen, a teacher, kind, steady, someone who had been there when I had only been promising to visit.
I read that letter sitting on the steps near the Ha’penny Bridge. I remember a busker singing “The Auld Triangle” and wanting to hate him for choosing such a sad song at such a convenient time. Clara wrote that she loved me once, and maybe still did in some corner of herself, but she was tired of loving a future that kept postponing itself. I folded the page carefully, put it back in the envelope, and did not reply.
She married him that August. I knew because a mutual friend showed me a photograph. Clara in a simple cream dress, hair pinned badly because she never had patience for perfection, smiling like someone trying to be brave. I told everyone I was fine. I worked, went to pubs with friends, stood at the bar in The Stag’s Head pretending the noise was company. But on my birthday that November, an envelope arrived.
There was no return address, only my name written in her unmistakable hand. Inside was a small card. “Happy birthday, Daniel. I hope Dublin is being gentle with you. C.” That was all. I kept it in a shoebox under my bed, alongside old cinema tickets and the first note she had ever written me, which said, “You look like you are lying about liking this film.”
The next year, another card came. Then another. Every birthday, without fail, Clara wrote to me. Sometimes it was one sentence. Sometimes a paragraph. She told me about the sea in Salthill, about a child she had lost before she ever got to hold it, about learning to bake brown bread, about her mother’s death, about ordinary days. She never said she regretted anything. She never asked to meet. She never signed more than “C.”
For a long time, those cards kept me from moving on properly. I compared every woman I dated to a girl in blue ink. I told myself the cards meant there was a door somewhere still open. But years have a way of being honest when people are not. By thirty-five, I understood that Clara was not writing to pull me back. She was writing because part of our lives had been real, and she did not want time to make a liar of it.
On my fortieth birthday, no card came. I waited three days, then a week. I told myself An Post had finally misplaced a piece of my heart. Two weeks later, I received a larger envelope, addressed by someone else. Inside was a letter from Stephen.
He wrote that Clara had died in September after an illness she had kept private from most people. He said she had left a small bundle of birthday cards in her desk, each labelled by year. “She asked me to send the last one,” he wrote. “I hope this does not hurt you. She spoke of you with great kindness.”
The final card was plain white. Her handwriting was weaker, but still hers. “Happy
Note: Please be aware that these are written in confidentiality and there is not reference or mention of any real people and their sentiments here. Every incident and Story tends to be emotional so please read at your own emotional risk. Website is not responsible for anything related. HumansofDublin.io is not related to the photography project HumansofDublin by Peter Varga
