I met Ciarán outside Whelan’s on a wet Thursday when we were both twenty-two and pretending we had somewhere better to be. I had lost my friends in the crowd, he had lost his jacket, and we stood under the same narrow awning laughing at the kind of rain that makes strangers honest. By the end of the night, we had shared chips on Camden Street and told each other things we probably should have saved for later.
For years after that, he was the person I rang when the world tilted. When my father died, Ciarán sat with me on the floor of my childhood bedroom in Raheny and folded funeral leaflets until two in the morning. When he was made redundant, I brought him coffee in St Stephen’s Green and let him swear at pigeons. He knew the ugly parts of me and never flinched. I mistook that for something it wasn’t, or maybe I hoped it would become enough.
By thirty, everyone around us was coupling off, buying houses in places we used to joke were too far from town, having babies with names that sounded like little poets. Ciarán and I were still each other’s emergency contact. People always said we made sense. His mother called me her daughter-in-law before there was a ring. My own mother, lonely since Dad’s death, told me a good man was not something to be taken lightly.
The proposal happened on Dollymount Strand, not in a dramatic way, but in a very Ciarán way. He had sand in his shoes and was nervous enough to keep talking about the tide. He said, “We’re good together, aren’t we?” and I said yes because we were. Then he asked me to marry him, and I remember looking at his face, so open and hopeful, and feeling an ache that I mistook for love. I said yes because I loved his kindness, his steadiness, the way my life felt safer with him in it. I did not understand then that loving someone’s presence is not the same as being in love with them.
Our wedding was small, in Dublin City Hall, followed by dinner near Temple Bar, where his uncle sang badly and my mother cried into her napkin. Everyone said it was perfect. I smiled in every photograph. Ciarán looked at me like he had found home. I looked at him like I was trying to memorise a map I could not read.
Marriage did not fall apart loudly. That was the problem. There were no slammed doors, no betrayals, no cruel words to point at and say, there, that is why. There was only the quiet horror of a good life that did not fit. We rented a flat in Portobello with a damp patch above the kitchen window. We cooked pasta, paid bills, watched crime dramas, met friends for pints. He reached for my hand in Tesco. He kissed the top of my head when he passed the sofa. I performed tenderness because I wanted to be worthy of his.
At night, I often lay awake listening to him breathe and felt a loneliness so sharp it frightened me. I would turn away and hate myself. He had done nothing wrong. He was gentle, funny, loyal. He remembered the anniversary of my father’s death and bought flowers for my mother. If love could be earned, he had earned it a thousand times.
The truth arrived one ordinary Sunday. We were walking along the Grand Canal, past the swans and the cyclists and the people carrying coffees like small comforts. Ciarán was talking about maybe trying for a baby the following year. He said it lightly, almost shyly, but I felt my chest close. I stopped walking. He turned back, smiling at first, and then he saw my face.
I wish I could say I found elegant words. I didn’t. I cried before I spoke. I told him I loved him, but not in the way he deserved. I told him I had tried, really tried, and that trying had become a kind of dishonesty. He stood very still. The city kept moving around us. A bus sighed at the lights. Someone laughed outside a café. My whole life seemed to narrow to the space between his eyes.
He asked, “Did you ever?”
I could have lied then. Part of me wanted to offer him that mercy. But he knew me too well, and I owed him the
Note: Please be aware that these are written in confidentiality and there is not reference or mention of any real people and their sentiments here. Every incident and Story tends to be emotional so please read at your own emotional risk. Website is not responsible for anything related. HumansofDublin.io is not related to the photography project HumansofDublin by Peter Varga
